Home › Guides

Is your credit card's annual fee worth it? Break-even for 19 Indian cards

Quick answer. A fee is worth paying if you spend more than its break-even on that card — from ₹23,100 a year for HSBC Live+ to ₹4,97,900 for Axis Magnus; the full table is below. But check your own terms first: most of the cards we could check waive the fee above a spending threshold — HDFC Millennia at ₹1,00,000, HSBC Live+ at ₹2,00,000, ICICI Coral at ₹1.5 lakh — and if you clear yours, your fee is zero and the break-even does not matter to you.

Based on the 23 Indian cards in our data — a subset of the market, not all of it; rates last checked between 2026-07-21 and 2026-08-16. Nineteen of them charge a fee, and those are the cards in the table.

Does your card waive the fee? Check this before anything else

Of the nineteen fee-charging cards below, we could read published fee terms for fifteen: fourteen publish a spending threshold that waives the annual fee, and one — Amex Platinum Travel — publishes none that we could find. Four SBI cards' pages returned no readable text, so for SBI Prime, SBI SimplyCLICK, IRCTC SBI Card and SBI Cashback the pages settle nothing either way; SBI Cashback's terms document has no spend-based fee reversal that we could find. Seven thresholds, in the issuers' own words:

• HDFC Millennia — "Spend over ₹1,00,000 in a year before renewal to get your Credit Card fee waived".
• HSBC Live+ — "Annual fee (waived if you spend more than INR200,000 per year)".
• ICICI Coral — "Spend over ₹1.5 lakh and get annual fee waived off for the next year".
• Amex Membership Rewards — the ₹4,500 renewal fee is "100% waived off if total spends on American Express Credit Card in the immediately preceding membership year is Rs.1,50,000 and above".
• HDFC Diners Club Black — "On annual spends of ₹5 lakh, get ₹10,000 renewal fee waived off".
• HDFC Infinia — "Spend ₹10 lakh or more in a year before the renewal date to get the renewal fee waived".
• Axis Magnus — "Annual fee of ₹12,500 + Taxes waived off* on spend of ₹25 Lakhs in preceding year".

Two of those thresholds sit far above the ₹5,22,000 of annual spending this page models — HDFC Infinia at ₹10 lakh and Axis Magnus at ₹25 lakh — so a reader at that level would still pay both fees; most of the others sit at or below it, but check your own terms for yours. Every row in the table assumes the fee is charged in full, because our data records a threshold for only one card — SBI Cashback at ₹2,00,000 — and we could not find that one in SBI's own terms. That makes the table a worst case, which is the right tool if you spend well under your card's threshold, or if your card has no waiver.

Do this: find your card's waiver threshold on the issuer's page. If you clear it comfortably, stop here — your fee is already zero. If you do not, or your card has none, the table below is for you.

How much do you need to spend for the fee to pay for itself?

Break-even is the annual spend at which a card's rewards exactly cover its annual fee. Spend more than this on the card and it pays for itself. Spend less and you are paying for the privilege of holding it.

Figures are rounded to the nearest hundred rupees. The four no-annual-fee cards in our India data have no break-even to clear — Amazon Pay ICICI, IDFC FIRST Select, IDFC FIRST WOW and Scapia Federal Bank.

‡ Two rows depend on a rate with a condition. The IRCTC SBI Card's break-even assumes its 10% transit rate, and SBI's own loyalty terms limit that to "up to 10%* value back of your AC class ticket fare", with "Reward Points" "not earned on 3E and SL Class tickets" — so unless you book AC train travel on it, its real break-even is far higher than the table shows. Axis Magnus's 2.51% assumes points redeemed at travel-transfer value through the Travel EDGE portal — a note in our own card data that we have not confirmed against Axis's terms.

Why is a cheap card sometimes the hardest to justify?

Because the fee on its own tells you very little. The fee divided by what the card really earns tells you almost everything. SBI SimplyCLICK charges ₹499 and needs ₹1,28,600 a year to break even. Axis ACE charges almost exactly the same fee and needs ₹35,700 — a quarter as much.

The easiest fee to justify belongs to a mid-fee card. HSBC Live+ costs ₹999 and breaks even at ₹23,100, because its 10% on dining and groceries earns hard against a small monthly ceiling. At low spending that ceiling barely binds, so the card earns 4.33% on the way to its break-even.

Premium cards are conditional, not indefensible. HDFC Infinia breaks even at ₹4,06,800 a year — about ₹33,900 a month. If your card spending genuinely runs at that level, the fee is a reasonable trade. If it does not, no amount of lounge access changes the arithmetic. Axis Magnus needs the most of any card here — ₹4,97,900 — despite a strong 2.51% rate, simply because ₹12,500 is a lot of fee to earn back.

If you are not sure what you actually put on each card in a year, that is the number Beni works from: your rough annual spend and your card names, never card numbers.

Do this: divide your card's fee by what it really earns you, not by its headline rate — the table's "rate at that spend" column is that number.

What this calculation leaves out

• Welcome bonuses. They flatter year one and vanish afterwards. A card that only makes sense with its joining bonus does not really make sense.
• Lounge access, insurance, concierge. Genuinely valuable to some people, worth nothing to others; putting a rupee figure on them would be inventing a number.
• Brand-locked merchant rates. Swiggy HDFC's 10%-on-Swiggy is real but only applies to Swiggy, so the engine excludes locked rates from this annual arithmetic. They are handled in the which-card-to-use guide.
• Exclusions beyond fuel. Some issuers exclude more than fuel — SBI's terms, for one, list rent, utilities, insurance, education and government payments — and the data behind these figures has categories for none of those, so it cannot apply them. Treat every break-even here as a floor: the real spend needed is at least this much.
• Fee waivers on spend thresholds — see the first section.

Questions people ask

Is HDFC Infinia's ₹12,500 fee worth it? Only if you spend more than ₹4,06,800 a year on it; below that, the ₹12,500 fee costs more than the card earns back. And HDFC waives the fee only above ₹10 lakh of spend, so at ₹5,22,000 you would still be paying it.

Which card's fee is easiest to earn back? HSBC Live+ — ₹999 a year, break-even ₹23,100 — and HSBC waives it above ₹2,00,000 of spend anyway.

Does the SBI Cashback ₹999 fee get waived? SBI's own terms document has no spend-based reversal that we could find, and SBI's product page would not load — check your own terms with SBI before you count on one.

How these numbers were made

Computed with Beni's own engine over 23 Indian cards, on a modelled ₹5,22,000 annual spending profile, with caps and stated fuel exclusions applied, scaled to solve each card's break-even; issuer quotes are from the documents linked. Fees and rates are estimates compiled from public issuer information and change without notice. Every India card in our data was last checked between 2026-07-21 and 2026-08-16 — confirm before you decide anything. Two cards here — IRCTC SBI Card and SBI SimplyCLICK, marked † — cannot be checked automatically. Full method and the corrections applied to the data: how these guides are made.

No affiliate links — Beni earns nothing whichever card you keep. Beni is not a bank, takes no payment, and never asks for card numbers.

Related

• Which credit card should you use for each purchase? (India)
• HDFC Millennia vs SBI Cashback: what actually separates them

To run this against your own spending rather than a modelled profile, Beni takes your rough annual figures and your card names — never card numbers — and computes it for your actual wallet.